A question of humes theory of personal identity the. Hume on identity over time and persons phil 20208 je. If the self was defined as just a bundle of successive conscious sensations, then of course, i dont think there. Terence penelhum, hume on personal identity philpapers. Hume did not believe in any notion of identity over time. This contains my own life and letter from adam smith, ll.
David humes philosophy on personal identity and bundle theory. Humes theory of personal identity is the one thing in which he confesses to having made considerable mistakes in the appendix to the treatise app. Mar 25, 2018 david hume s philosophy on personal identity and bundle theory. Personal identity, the self, the appendix to treaties, bundle theory, intuition. First, there is the reductive theory set out in the main body of the treatise, and.
In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content hume studies volume xix, number 2, november 1993, pp. Hume and parfit on the question of personal identity. Pdf in this paper, i present an informational approach to the nature of. Biro as hume s theory of the self a logicalconstruction theory.
Yet it is striking that hume does not emphasize lockes distinction between persons and human beings. Clearly, it is going to be hard to tackle a problem that plato, hume and kant. University of hawaii press is collaborating with jstor to. Hume s theory of personal identity is developed in response to lockes account of personal identity. Are there similarities between lockes and humes views. Locke and hume on personal identity locke and hume both discuss the idea of personal identity in connection with certain general claims about the very idea of identity in a more general sense and i am going to begin, prior to discussing personal identity in particular, with a comparison of their specific treatments of the general idea of identity. For, he thought, when we encounter several different things existing in succession and differing gradually, one from the next. However, once the problem has been construed in these terms, it is plain that too much has already been assumed. In this paper, i will demonstrate that hume presents a positive and constructive view of the self in his discussion of the. Hume thought that this tendency goes a long way towards explaining mistaken views about personal identity. Hume, buddhism, and personal identity the problem of personal identity is often said to be one of accounting for what it is that gives persons their identity over time. Hume sums up the discussion of personal identity by saying that his whole examination of this question reveals that most of the disputes about personal identity are merely verbal he says it is a grammitical rather than a philosophical problem. Dialogue on personal identity and immortality by john perry i assign john perrys dialogue on personal identity and immortality for a lively, accessible introduction to arguments for and against the three candidates for.
Paragraph numbering was not included in the original text and has been added for ease of. Similar to the other presented theories, humes account on personal identity is subject to criticism. Adistinct idea of an object that remains invariable and. I shall further suggest that such an interpretation. He comes to the idea that selfbeing can not exist because since the emotions that create this selfexistence contradict itself when it is in the process. The perception of self is a subjective interpretation of reality and is necessarily colored by the subjects own preconceived notions of self. He must show how these two types of association combine in. David hume of personal identity flashcards quizlet. First, there is the reductive theory set out in the main body of the treatise, and then in the appendix there is the recantation of that theory. At the opening of the treatise, ideas and impressions are distinguished by their degrees of vivacity.
Memory is essential to personal identity, as it is memory which allows us the impression of a continuity of perceptions, and so in turn, the idea of cause and effect. Pdf this paper investigates the topic of personal identity in standard. On the other hand, penelhum reads very strong theses in humes account of personal identity. In david humes of personal identity, he makes his argument that the idea of existence is falsified. For followers of hume, a true, objective observation of reality is impossible. While descartes does not pontificate the details of such identity to the extent in which locke does there is a very evident connection between his view of epistemology and identity. Hume on personal identity1 corliss gayda swain a number of papers recently published on hume s theory of personal identityhavebeen devoted to the question. Introduction hume s contribution to the field of personal identity has never gained the attention it deserves, but it is hard to put a finger on exactly why. In the previous section, he has rejected the ancient philosophys posit of a mental substance, or soul, in which the perceptions of the mind are said to inhere, and has argued that, in fact, each perception fits the definition of substance as something which may exist by itself. David hume, a skeptic, takes a different approach to the idea of personal identity.
David hume, of personal identity from a treatise of human nature, 1739 there are some philosophers, who imagine we are every moment intimately conscious of what we call our self. Locke argues both that person is a forensic term and that personal identity consists in sameness of consciousness i argue that the best way to reconcile these two claims is to interpret locke as giving a. The most significant features of humes work, as understood by reid, are the representive theory of perception, the nature of causation and causal concepts, the nature of personal identity and the. Hume delivers his account of personal identity in treatise 1. Of personal identity david hume there are some philosophers who imagine we are every moment intimately conscious of what we call our self. Desh raj sirswal 2005 bihar jounal of philosophical research 00. How does hume respond to lockes memory theory of personal identity. This is a posthumous edition from humes unpublished manuscript, and contains his most detailed attack on natural religion. In his of personal identity, 1 david hume criticizes the idea of personal identity. Locke but once memory has done its work, then our personal identity can be extended even to times forgotten. Locke argues both that person is a forensic term and that personal identity consists in sameness of consciousness i argue that the best way to reconcile these two claims is to interpret locke as giving a moral account of personhood which. Humes discussion on the personal identity philosophical. But since the identity of a personality is the constituents of its perceptual bundle, and those constituents are always in flux.
In brief, hume is unable to reconcile the naturalistic view with his methodological solipsism. Personal identity does not exist, in the same way, as other ordinary objects, and in a sense, could be said not to exist at all. Interview with locke and hume assume you have the opportunity to interview locke and hume on personal identity. The ways in which objects remain the same constitutes their identity. I propose to examine the recently revived claim1 that it is and to argue that it rests on a superficial reading of humes remarks on personal identity in the treatise. Keywordsegopoiesisphilosophy of informationpersonal identityself. Hume and parfit on the question of personal identity i enjoyed humes and parfits readings on the question of personal identity. These two pieces of information are connected with one another, and in nigel denniss novel cards of identity the victims are deprived of both at once. Consciousness, self, and personal identity u2 writing assignment maggie mccoy what identifies a. He thinks, for instance, that according to hume we commit an abuse of language every time we use the same word to designate a changing entity, and a fortiori, every time we use the same name to call a person 9. Personal identity in memento plato philosophy learning. A question of humes theory of personal identity the oxford. Jul 12, 2014 the most significant features of hume s work, as understood by reid, are the representive theory of perception, the nature of causation and causal concepts, the nature of personal identity and the.
Hume s discussion of personal identity concludes with a striking claim. Defending humes theory of personal identity and discarding the appendix. Humes view of what constitutes personal identity rests heavily upon his preceding theories concerning the nature of ideas and causation. There are some philosophers who imagine we are every moment intimately conscious of what we call our self. In this paper, i argue for an interpretation of the passage in humes treatise where he talks about the fiction called personal identity. Hume argued that mans tendency to give meaning to correlating qualities colored the perception of self.
A collection of perceptions and impressions i can never catch myself at any time without a perception and never can observe anything but the perception. Hume begins his discussion of personal identity by, strikingly, denying that we have any idea of the self. Humes positive theory of personal identity 151 various causes which produce these passions. There is little consensus, however, on what exactly was the source of his discontent. A treatise of human nature, by david hume project gutenberg. Biro as humes theory of the self a logicalconstruction theory. Pdf personal identity and standard economic theory researchgate. David hume on personal identity a treatise concerning human nature 1739. The most important preceding ideas to take into account are the rejection of causality and necessary connection and his strict empiric stance on the basis of knowledge and the only two types of perception being ideas that are reliant on initial impressions. Concerning theories of personal identity usf scholar commons.
Humes positive theory of personal identity bradley m. This paper considers hume s account of personal identity in his treatise of human nature. In this paper i will summarize my examination of the first two topic areas only. The identity which we ascribe to the mind of man is only a fictitious one 168. Oct 12, 2008 i need help understanding some things on john lockes of identity and diversity and david hume s of personal identity can you help. I propose to examine the recently revived claim1 that it is and to argue that it rests on a superficial reading of hume s remarks on personal identity in the treatise. Are there similarities between lockes and hume s views. Hume believes that the self is an illusion or a fiction. There are some philosophers, who imagine we are every. Excerpts relating to personal identity from david humes a treatise on human nature,1739 it must be some one impression, that gives rise to every real idea. The perception of self is a subjective interpretation of reality and is.
He considers memories to take over an essential part in creating personal identity, but avoids the problem of forgetfulness in declaring causality to be the connection allowing us to extend identity beyond memory. The whole of this doctrine leads us to a conclusion, which is of great importance in the present a. Hume locke vs hume consciousness self and personal identity u2 writing assignment maggie mccoy what identifies a person is it their memories. Lasse nielsen download pdf download epub download mobi print. In a paper called hume on personal identity, penelhum argues that hume s account is an immense blunder, an excellent example of how complex and farreaching the consequences of a mistake in linguistic analysis or conceptual investigation can be. But self or person is not any one impression, but that to which our several impressions and ideas are supposd to have a reference. How do you characterize between a lockean view and a humean view. I need help understanding some things on john lockes of identity and diversity and david humes of personal identity can you help. There are no persons that continue to exist over time. Porath citrus college one of the most vexed topics in hume scholarship is his position regarding personal identity. David hume argued that there is no simple, constant self to be found within a persons aggregate experiences and actions throughout their conscious life. I never can catch myself at any time without a perception, and never can observe any thing but the perception. The evident connexion presents a new reading of humes bundle theory of the self or mind, and his later rejection of it.
Hume from phil 1001 at georgia southwestern state university. For my part, when i enter most intimately into what i call myself, i always stumble on some particular perception or other, of heat or cold, light or shade, love or hatred, pain or pleasure. Start studying summary david hume of personal identity. David hume believed that while people may have notions of some unchanging personal characteristics embedded within themselves, people have actually mistaken their perceptions of themselves as the genuine article. Philosophy through film, routledge, 2002 by mary litch for further reading on personal identity in memento.
The treatment of personal identity in hume s treatise displays a shift that is both interesting as an object lesson in the weakness of a particular sort of empirical project, and important for what it teaches about investigating moral life. Aw 526a necessitates a continuous impression of the self. But it is easy to see that they are different things, and the philosophical problem of personal identity is in fact concerned with only one of them particular identity. In the appendix to a treatise of human nature, david hume. The personal and social nature of identity gives the construct its greatest theoretical potentialnamely to provide insight into the relationship between the individual and society. That this is only half the story becomes apparent both in humes discussion of on scepticism with regard to the senses and in his account of the fiction of personal identity. In lieu of an abstract, here is a brief excerpt of the content being sure of ones self. Galen strawson argues that the bundle theory does not claim that there are no subjects of experience. What does hume mean when he says in paragraph two that human beings are a bundle.
The section concerning personal identity to which humes. David hume, true to his extreme skepticism, rejects the notion of identity over time. Concerning theories of personal identity patrick bailey abstract the purpose of this thesis is to provide a brief examination of the historical accounts of philosophical theories of personal identity and show the influence that each has had on the development of contemporary theories. Paragraph numbering was not included in the original text and has been added for ease of reference. Apr 23, 2012 hume s view of what constitutes personal identity rests heavily upon his preceding theories concerning the nature of ideas and causation. Learn vocabulary, terms, and more with flashcards, games, and other study tools. Hume s positive theory of personal identity bradley m. In contrast to descartes, lockes theory of personal cannot be understand prima facie from his epistemic view, but nonetheless is a groundbreaking contribution. Pdf the informational nature of personal identity researchgate.
Humes account of person al identity by david pears humes account of personal identity is superior to most other accounts because it is more penetrating. Hume on personal identity1 corliss gayda swain a number of papers recently published on humes theory of personal identityhavebeen devoted to the question. Humes skeptical questioning of the notion of a self is quite astonishing given the time period in which he wrote. One of the problems with this discussion, that penelhum also remarks upon hume on personal identity, pp. In a paper called hume on personal identity, penelhum argues that humes account is an immense blunder, an excellent example of how complex and farreaching the consequences of a mistake in linguistic analysis or conceptual investigation can be. The objects of the mind vary along a single dimension of force and vivacity. Similar to the other presented theories, humes account on. Whyin the appendix to the treatise did hume express complete or acute dissatisfaction with his account of personal identity in book 1 of that work. Dec 08, 2011 in his of personal identity, 1 david hume criticizes the idea of personal identity. Introduction the problems of personal identity the persistence question the population question the personalontology question the question of what matters in identity the persistence question. Summary david hume of personal identity flashcards. Defending humes theory of personal identity and discarding the.
438 693 804 57 1461 1224 1087 1178 1143 139 783 705 592 114 146 1148 528 17 709 1337 216 671 1511 686 334 424 791 1244 1020 1420 1085 1022 1127 1209 903 590 1371 1240 23 1296